Letter 4011: Gregory to Maximianus, Bishop of Syracuse. It had indeed been committed to your Fraternity long ago by our authority to correct in our stead any excesses or unseemly proceedings that there might be in the Church and other venerable places of Sicily. But, seeing that a complaint has reached us of some things having been so far neglected, we have ...
Pope Gregory the Great→Maximianus, of Syracuse|c. 593 AD|gregory great
monasticismproperty economics
Theological controversy; Military conflict; Economic matters
Gregory to Maximianus, Bishop of Syracuse.
We entrusted to your Fraternity long ago the authority to correct, in our name, any abuses or improper practices in the churches and other sacred institutions of Sicily. But since we have received complaints that some matters have been neglected, we think it right to press your Fraternity again on specific points.
We have learned that the canonical division of church revenues into four parts is not being applied to newly acquired income. Instead, the bishops of the various dioceses distribute a fourth from the old revenues only, keeping the new income for themselves. Your Fraternity must act swiftly to eliminate this corrupt custom. Whether the revenues are old or new, the four-part division must be observed according to canonical rules. It is improper for the same Church property to be treated under two different standards — one of arbitrary appropriation and one of canonical law.
Do not permit presbyters, deacons, or other clergy of any rank who serve churches to simultaneously hold the office of abbot over a monastery. They must either give up their clerical duties and commit fully to the monastic life, or, if they choose to remain as abbots, they must not be allowed to continue in any clerical role. It is entirely unsuitable for a person to claim both positions when he cannot properly fulfill even one. The ecclesiastical order must not obstruct the monastic life, nor should monastic obligations undermine ecclesiastical duties.
We also wish to alert you to this: if any bishop should die, his archdeacon must not be allowed to seize control of the church's property or claim any authority over it, lest the resources meant for the church be squandered.
Book IV, Letter 11
To Maximianus, Bishop.
Gregory to Maximianus, Bishop of Syracuse.
It had indeed been committed to your Fraternity long ago by our authority to correct in our stead any excesses or unseemly proceedings that there might be in the Church and other venerable places of Sicily. But, seeing that a complaint has reached us of some things having been so far neglected, we have thought it fit that your Fraternity should again be specially stirred up to correct them.
For we learn that in the case of revenues of Churches that have been newly acquired the canonical disposition of their fourth parts does not prevail , but that the bishops of the several places distribute a fourth part of the ancient revenues only, retaining for their own use those that have been recently acquired. Wherefore let your Fraternity make haste actively to correct this evil custom that has crept in, so that, whether in the case of former revenues or of such as have accrued now or may accrue, the fourth parts may be dispensed according to the canonical distribution of them. For it is unseemly that one and the same substance of the Church should be rated, as it were, under two different laws, namely, that of usurpation and that of the canons.
Permit not presbyters, deacons, and other clerks of whatever order, who serve churches, to be abbots of monasteries; but let them either, giving up clerical duties, be advanced to the monastic order, or, if they should decide to remain in the position of abbot, let them by no means be allowed to have clerical employment. For it is very unsuitable that, if one cannot fulfil the duties of either of these positions with diligence proportional to its importance, any one should be judged fit for both, and that so the ecclesiastical order should impede the monastic life, and in turn the rule of monasticism impede ecclesiastical utility. Of this thing also we have taken thought to warn your Charity; that, if any one of the bishops should depart this life, or (which God forbid) should be removed for his transgressions, the hierarchs and all the chief of the clergy being assembled, and in your presence making an inventory of the property of the Church, all that is found should be accurately described, and nothing should be taken away in kind, or in any other way whatever, from the property of the Church, as is said to have been done formerly, as though in return for the trouble of making the inventories. For we desire all that pertains to the protection of what belongs to the poor to be so executed that in their affairs no opportunity may be left for the venality of self-interested men.
Let visitors of churches, and their clerks who with them are at trouble in parishes that are not of their own city, receive according to your appointment some subsidy for their labour. For it is just that they should get payment in the places where they are found to lend their services.
We most strongly forbid young women to be made abbesses. Let your Fraternity, therefore, permit no bishop to veil any but a sexagenarian virgin, whose age and character may demand this being done; that so, this as well as the above-named points being set right with the Lord's help by the urgency of your strict requirement, you may hasten to bind up again with canonical ties the long loosened state of venerable things, and also that divine affairs may be arranged, not by the incongruous wills of men, but with adequate strictness. The month of October, Indiction 12.
About this page
Source. Translated by James Barmby. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Second Series, Vol. 12. Edited by Philip Schaff and Henry Wace. (Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1895.) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/360204011.htm>.
Contact information. The editor of New Advent is Kevin Knight. My email address is feedback732 at newadvent.org. (To help fight spam, this address might change occasionally.) Regrettably, I can't reply to every letter, but I greatly appreciate your feedback — especially notifications about typographical errors and inappropriate ads.
◆
Gregory to Maximianus, Bishop of Syracuse.
We entrusted to your Fraternity long ago the authority to correct, in our name, any abuses or improper practices in the churches and other sacred institutions of Sicily. But since we have received complaints that some matters have been neglected, we think it right to press your Fraternity again on specific points.
We have learned that the canonical division of church revenues into four parts is not being applied to newly acquired income. Instead, the bishops of the various dioceses distribute a fourth from the old revenues only, keeping the new income for themselves. Your Fraternity must act swiftly to eliminate this corrupt custom. Whether the revenues are old or new, the four-part division must be observed according to canonical rules. It is improper for the same Church property to be treated under two different standards — one of arbitrary appropriation and one of canonical law.
Do not permit presbyters, deacons, or other clergy of any rank who serve churches to simultaneously hold the office of abbot over a monastery. They must either give up their clerical duties and commit fully to the monastic life, or, if they choose to remain as abbots, they must not be allowed to continue in any clerical role. It is entirely unsuitable for a person to claim both positions when he cannot properly fulfill even one. The ecclesiastical order must not obstruct the monastic life, nor should monastic obligations undermine ecclesiastical duties.
We also wish to alert you to this: if any bishop should die, his archdeacon must not be allowed to seize control of the church's property or claim any authority over it, lest the resources meant for the church be squandered.
Modern English rendering for readability. See the 19th-century translation or original Latin/Greek for scholarly use.